Growing up in the church I was taught that revelations and doctrines build upon one another in a linear upward path, “line upon line, precept upon precept, here a little and there a little”. Not only do doctrines build upon one another, but they also don’t contradict one another and have always been the same because they are founded on never-changing truth. It is often heard that “the gospel is the same no matter what dispensation you live in”, we have just been brought back to the truth (doctrine) through the Restoration. Based on these ideas I made the logical jump to believe that Ancient Israel knew the sublime truths of the Plan of Salvation, temple work, etc. I was even privy to have seminary teachers point out snippets from the Old and New Testament to back up these ideas.
For some time now I have seen that the story is not so pretty. I loved the clean story of my youth and early adulthood because it makes a whole lot of sense in the Mormon paradigm of a loving and highly organized God. The conclusion that doctrines and teachings shift with time, culture, and people was solidifying in my mind prior to reading “This Is My Doctrine”: The Development of Mormon Theology by Charles Harrell. After reading This Is My Doctrine (TIMD) the messy version is more concrete in my mind.
Professor Harrell does a thorough analysis of “how doctrines taught today appear to have been understood in early Mormonism and earlier Old and New Testament times.” A basic doctrine, such as the Priesthood or Final Judgement, is the subject of each chapter, which is then taken through the perspectives and interpretations of believers during several time periods: Old Testament, New Testament, Early Mormonism, Early Nineteenth-Century Christian, Early Mormon (1828-1830), Nauvoo-Period (1835-1844), Later Mormon, and Contemporary Mormon times. Relying heavily on the critical biblical scholars and archaeologists he is able to formulate the doctrines of religious followers centuries and even millennia ago.
Harrell obviously knows that reading the core chapters of the book are not the most faith promoting. This is especially true if read with the intention of looking for a beautiful picture of how Mormonism’s doctrine, God’s people’s doctrine, has been the same through all times. At times it may seem that the book is refuting LDS doctrines. I myself felt this way after reading section after section on doctrines that do not correlate well with what the current understood doctrines are. I see now that I still wanted to hold onto at least a portion of the clarity found in universal doctrines I grew up with. In the preface and the epilogue he makes a good attempt to explain his purpose due to the critical nature of the text contained in the book. He is very direct in saying that, although he is an active LDS man, the purpose of the book is “meant to be neither apologetic nor polemic”.
TIMD is large in its scope and well researched. Notes abound throughout the text and the book ends with a 37 page bibliography.To many it may be a good reference book, but I found it fascinating enough to read straight through. It was fascinating to see ideas be added, taken away, transformed, or slightly bent to match the understandings, culture, or spiritual inclinations of the time period. Proof-texting, lifting a scriptural passage out of its original context and giving it an interpretation other than that which was originally intended, is a major element of each chapter. It was enlightening to me to find that the interpretations of biblical scholars seemed more compelling to me than modern LDS interpretations. TIMD fills in all of the context of the time period and informs you of what appears to be the intent of the scripture. A lot of the time an Old Testament verse appears to be saying something much more direct when taken in context when compared to the current LDS interpretation.
Some may find TIMD challenging or even unpalatable, but to me it is a work of great courage and insight. It says to me “do not fear the complexity and faults of the doctrine, understand them and grow from them.” I think the title of the first chapter explains it all…Theology, A Divine-Human Enterprise.
Catch interviews with Charles Harrell here:
Truth in Revelation and Scripture – Mormon Matters
Mormon “Doctrine” and Other Fuzzy Things – Mormon Matters
BYU Professor Charles Harrell and the Evolution of Mormon Doctrine – Mormon Stories
Excellent post Matthew. I feel this book is required reading for anyone wanting to have an uncorrelated, un-whitewashed yet wholly accurate version of Christian/Mormon doctrine evolution. Its a tough pill to swallow, but we can’t move on to accurate understandings and therefore holistic improvements without understanding what this book shows.
I completely agree that it would definitely increase understanding and sympathy for other Christians and even Jews. That willingness is the key though. Are you willing to take the red pill over the blue pill?
It appears that the red pill / blue pill analogy has been removed from this article.
Great review. After listening to Dr. Harrell’s interview on Mormon Stories, I went out and bought his book. I am ashamed to say that it is still in shrink-wrap. We should post a link to his MoSto interview on here as well as his appearance on Mormon Matters.
Great review… I need to pick this baby up soon!
Paul, I have the book.
Dude bring it up so I can add it to my pile of books that I need to read
Thanks for the thoughtful and charitable review. Any attempt to address LDS theology in a critical fashion is admittedly risky and bound to draw a variety of responses. It was my hope that readers would react the way you have and be willing to reconsider traditional LDS doctrinal narratives and recognize that LDS theology is much more nuanced and complex than what most of us have traditionally been taught. Such a recognition can bring discomfort, but in the end I believe that the increased empathy it gives us towards others in their faith journey and the added perspective it gives to our understanding of how revelation works are invaluable.
I appreciate the comment Professor Harrell. Always gratifying to hear from the author himself.
I must agree with all of your comments. It takes a certain paradigm and humble spirit to process over 500 pages of complexity and contradictions.
Thank you for a challenging and great book.
The amount of material referenced in the book is enormous, so I must ask how long did it take you to produce the book? I am assuming that you started compiling information years and years before the book was even in draft form.
Pursuing theological history only as a hobby, it has taken several decades to research, sort through and compile the information. The Google Books project, which has made thousands of books and periodicals and other literature available from Joseph Smith’s era, was invaluable as it enabled even a hobbyist like me to obtain a fairly comprehensive perspective of the religious world of Joseph Smith and gain a much better appreciation for the religious discourse of early Mormonism (including the Book of Mormon).
This review/overview has convinced me to buy the book. I was already considering it after the Mormon Stories & Mormon Matters discussions but this write-up has finished convincing me it is worth my time. Thanks.
It is a solid read. I am glad the review made a difference.